Wednesday, October 8, 2008

issues:

The thesis proposal that I have come up with is far more localized than some of the theories tackling architecture as a whole, or trying to define architecture.... mine seeks to simply find a way to relate old and new. I'm taking something I see as an issue, yes, but it is not of the same scale as some of the 'architectural greats'. Mine is far more specific, and yet I still have a great deal of freedom of interpretation. It's like how we discussed whether Hannes and LeCorb's manifestos could be applied to any project or whether they would be too prescriptive. I think that even my problem and project statements are very open ended as far as how one might apply them. The basic concept is there, but how do I put it into play is an issue I am struggling with as we approach the deadline for program. I'm finding the issue to not be one of program, but of site. I feel like the site will determine the program, help to define the concept even further, and basically arrange the project for me. This makes the stress of choosing a site even more acute. I feel as though I have backed myself into a corner, where I must choose and analyze the site before I can even begin to consider program. Whereas I have a very broad concept, that can be applied anywhere, the prescriptive nature of my thesis requires the individual concept application to a unique place and situation. I am wondering how this can be absolved without harming the nature of my thesis through the over-prescription of site requirements, or the over-simplification from generalizing my site specific project to support my more overarching thesis.

1 comment:

luis said...

yes, that is the big conundrum ... should site come before program... and, in some cases, it should... (like, perhaps, yours)...

so, what site are you thinking about?
and how do you solve for it?

broad is better (remember mateo)... so, now the site becomes crucial... so, pick a site... generically think about its program requirements...

so, where do you choose? barcelona, buenos aires, cape town, mumbai, paris, vienna... ?

and then, specifically where: around the poble nou, recolteta, city bowl, vashi, the 19th arrondissement, landstrasse... ???? see every site has different programmatic charges that can guide....